Channels
 India News
 National
 World
 Business
 Sports
 Cricket
 Entertainment
 Bollywood
 Stock Market
 Voices
 Blog
 
 News
 New Delhi
 Mumbai
 Bangalore
 Hyderabad
 Chennai
 Goa
 by City
 by State
 
 People
 Aishwarya Rai
 Salman Khan
 Acting
 Movies
 More Celebs
 India Blogs
 
 Resources
 Indian Recipes
 Flights to India
 
 Links
 India Jobs
 India Arcade
 
DRM Woes — I Told Ya So!

April 23rd, 2008


by Michael Swanberg

To those that said such things couldn’t or wouldn’t happen, here’s some back up of my point.

Not so long ago I posted a blog about DRM and its evils. To me, the biggest is that DRM’ed music isn’t purchased at all. It’s only rented. Eventually, any DRM scheme that depends on heading out to the interweb to authorize the user is doomed to eventual shutdown.

According to an Engadget article MSN is already shutting down its support for the MSN Music service. They even mention iTunes (as I did), even though it was a bit of hyperbolistic fear-mongering. But it is true. If you purchase a record or a cassette tape or a CD or a DRM-free song, you and your children and your grandchildren can have access to this music. However, DRM’ed tracks are doomed to eventual uselessness.

I don’t want to discourage purchase of music online. Lord knows this is an excellent distribution medium, and we don’t want the short-sighted RIAA to believe that no money can be made with this strategem. But I would like to make it abundantly clear that any track you purchase online has a finite life, if it is crippled with DRM.

Therefore, purchase DRM-free whenever possible. And if you can release your music from DRM (analog hole, for example), that’s probably a great way to future-proof your music collection. I know that’s my SOP.

Good luck!

Share This Article: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • IndianPad
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati


2 Comments for “DRM Woes — I Told Ya So!”

manpan Says:

I have software like DRM Dumpster to remove the DRM in iTunes purchased tracks. I haven’t really used it yet — they require you use re-writable CDR-Ws and burn the disc once with all the protected music and then with DRM Dumpster convert to unprotected files and re-burn to disc. In future the unprotected versions of protected tracks must remain in the library with the protected tracks if the user chooses to still keep protected tracks in their library — they do this so in future DRM Dumpster will know what songs its already removed the DRM from and won’t make the mistake of re-ripping the DRM from tracks that have already been converted to DRM free.

Now I’m just exploring possibilities to do the same with my videos bought on iTunes. The best thing I can think of is getting Apple TV hookup to an HD TV with VCR and DVD Recorder/Player and get the purchased and copy protected iTunes video content to play on my high definition television (which I am buying later this year) and then re-record it to VHS. I could buy blank VHS tapes — I know VHS in the movie industry for buying movies on VHS is dead but in video stores blank VHS tapes are being sold.

I would record to DVR but then won’t be able to retrieve it and don’t know if the recording would stay or get erased due to DRM.

Michael Swanberg Says:

I used to use HYMN and JHYMN to bust the DRM off of iTunes tracks. But they’ve seemed to have given up on keeping up with Apple and the iTunes updates. The result: I try NOT to buy songs from iTunes anymore.

HYMN was a great idea. It removed the DRM but left the user’s fingerprints on the file so that if they tried to distribute it illegally, it would be easy to find out who did it. But Apple slit their own wrists on several occasions where HYMN is concerned. First, they started LOOKING for the non-DRM tracks that still had the fingerprints, and then refusing to play them. So HYMN changed to remove all traces of the purchaser. That probably put more music straight from iTunes onto the pirated list. Second, Apple kept updating iTunes, so HYMN seems to have given up on trying to stay ahead. The result there: I buy from Amazon (or else I buy the CDs). Apple could have beaten Wal-Mart even quicker if they’d not put so much effort into defeating HYMN.

This DRM Dumpster sounds like it uses the so-called “analog hole” (it isn’t really analog, however) to burn and re-rip tracks. This is, of course, always an option. But it should be noted that the quality of each track is reduced with this process.

-Mike

Leave a Comment


« AppleTV Redux Revisited Take 2 Another Time Around Namecheap Coupon Codes »
Copyright © 2004-2008 DailyIndia.com
India News